craftsmanship software jfall

Craftsmanship, Practice or Procreation?

Iwein Fuld

In the past years there has been much ado about the quality of software. Programmers have emancipated and evolved into software craftsmen. Metrics have been defined and honed to measure the quality of code and deliverable artifacts. More and more of our clients are asking for guidance in achieving higher and higher quality goals.

The discussion about software craftsmanship hasn’t been all positive. Many developers that I’ve worked with express the feeling that certain levels of quality are only driven by the personal gratification of craftsmen and not in line with the economic realities of our trade. In this article I strive to establish guidelines in the compromise between quality and speed. I feel it is warranted to be more nuanced than the simplistic statement: “Going fast by going well”. This is because “going well” can mean different things in different contexts.

I look for a line in the sand between improving quality to improve procreation and improving quality for mere self indulgent practice.

 Read more